Honest questions
What happens when we die?
The New Testament's main hope is not disembodied souls in the clouds but resurrection: bodies raised, creation renewed, God present with his people. Between death and that day, the usual Christian reading is that believers are consciously with Christ. Details beyond that are thinner in Scripture than a great deal of popular teaching admits.
Resurrection, not merely an afterlife
The hope the New Testament spends the most words on is bodily: the dead raised, a new heaven and a new earth, and God dwelling with people rather than people relocating to God. Paul's longest treatment of death, in 1 Corinthians 15, is about a body that is buried perishable and raised imperishable. This matters because it says the physical world is not a phase to be escaped. Whatever else Christians hope for, they hope for their bodies back, in a world that has been put right.
The time in between
What happens between dying and that day is described far more briefly. Paul says departing means being with Christ and calls it better. He also says being absent from the body is being at home with the Lord. Jesus tells a dying man he will be with him that day. Most Christians take these as conscious presence with Christ while awaiting resurrection. A minority tradition reads the language of sleep in Scripture as unconsciousness until the resurrection. Both sides work from the same short set of texts.
Judgment, and where Christians differ
Scripture is consistent that there is judgment and that final separation from God is real. On what that means in the end, there is a genuine range within Christian orthodoxy: the traditional and majority view of conscious eternal punishment, the annihilationist view that the lost finally cease to exist, and a minority hope that God's mercy proves wider than we can currently see. Each argues from Scripture, each has serious defenders, and Trinity states all three rather than presenting one as obvious.
Grief, and what this is for
Paul does not tell the Thessalonians to stop grieving. He tells them not to grieve as people with no hope, which is a much smaller instruction than it is often made to be. Christian hope is not a reason to hurry through mourning or to hand a bereaved person a doctrine. If you are reading this because someone has died, the honest thing to say is that the New Testament's answer is a promise rather than a consolation prize, and that promises take time to feel like anything.
In the text
Where this comes from
Quoted from the World English Bible, which is public domain. Read the surrounding chapter in whatever translation you own.
So also is the resurrection of the dead. The body is sown perishable; it is raised imperishable.
But I am in a dilemma between the two, having the desire to depart and be with Christ, which is far better.
For the Lord himself will descend from heaven with a shout, with the voice of the archangel and with God's trumpet. The dead in Christ will rise first.
Keep going
Related questions
Ask Trinity the rest of it
A page can only go so far. Bring the version of this question you actually have, in your own words, and work through the passages with a tutor that will not rush you.
Join the waitlist